“Whereas India’s whole imports from the UAE fell 9.8% from $53.2 billion in FY23 to $48 billion in FY24, imports of gold and silver skyrocketed 210%, from $3.5 billion to $10.7 billion,” GTRI report mentioned.
| Picture Credit score: Reuters

“India’s gold and silver imports from its free commerce settlement (FTA) companion UAE have skyrocketed 210% to $10.7 billion in 2023-24 and there’s a must doubtlessly revise the concessional customs responsibility charges beneath the pact to mitigate the arbitrage driving this surge,” a report mentioned on June 17.

Financial suppose tank World Commerce Analysis Initiative (GTRI) mentioned this sharp rise in gold and silver imports is primarily pushed by import responsibility concessions granted by India to the UAE beneath the India-UAE Complete Financial Partnership Settlement (CEPA).

India permits 7% tariffs or customs responsibility concessions on import of limitless portions of silver and a 1% concession on 160 metric tonnes of gold. CEPA was signed in February 2022 and carried out in Might 2022.

Moreover, India facilitates gold and silver imports by permitting non-public corporations to import from the UAE by way of the India Worldwide Bullion Trade (IIBX) in Reward Metropolis. “Beforehand, solely authorised businesses might deal with such imports,” the report mentioned.

“Whereas India’s whole imports from the UAE fell 9.8% from $53.2 billion in FY23 to $48 billion in FY24, imports of gold and silver skyrocketed 210%, from $3.5 billion to $10.7 billion,” it mentioned.

“Import of all remaining merchandise fell 25%, from $49.7 billion in FY23 to %37.3 billion in FY24,” it mentioned. GTRI Founder Ajay Srivastava mentioned the present import of gold and silver from the UAE is unsustainable because the UAE doesn’t mine gold or silver or add ample worth to imports.

“Excessive import duties in India on gold, silver, and jewelry at 15% are on the root of the issue. Contemplate decreasing tariffs to five per cent. It will lower large-scale smuggling and different misuse,” Mr. Srivastava mentioned.

Commerce in gold, silver, and diamonds has been vulnerable to misuse as a consequence of their low quantity however excessive worth and excessive import duties in India. “Low tariff imports of gold, silver solely profit few importers who hold all earnings arising by way of tariff arbitrage and by no means cross it to shoppers,” he mentioned.

Mr. Srivastava prompt the federal government implement sure measures to assist India steadiness its commerce insurance policies, shield home income, and guarantee honest competitors within the import of treasured metals and jewelry. It prompt reassessing and doubtlessly revising the concessional responsibility charges beneath CEPA to mitigate the arbitrage driving the surge in imports of gold and silver.

“At the least, implement yearly import quotas (tariff price quotas) for silver, much like these for gold, to manage the quantity of imports and forestall income loss,” it mentioned, including that India ought to rigorously confirm the claimed worth addition by Dubai-based refiners in gold and silver imports to make sure compliance with CEPA guidelines of origin.

It additionally requested to tighten laws across the India Worldwide Bullion Trade (IIBX) at Reward Metropolis to manage the quantity and nature of treasured metallic imports and the alternate shouldn’t permit country-based exemptions.

As elevated imports contribute to the next present account deficit and since gold and silver act extra like monetary devices than common commerce gadgets, India ought to keep away from together with them in any FTA.

“India has granted tariff concessions for these things in lots of FTAs and beneath the DFTP (duty-free tariff desire) scheme, so a complete evaluation is required.

India introduced the scheme for LDCs (least developed nations) in 2008. Beneath this, India offers responsibility free/preferential market entry on about 98.2% of India’s tariff strains (or product classes).

Additional, the report said that silver imports from the UAE elevated multifold to $1.74 billion in 2023-24 from a meagre $29.2 million in 2022-23 as a consequence of India charging an 8% responsibility beneath the CEPA versus a 15% responsibility from different nations.

“The big 7% tariff arbitrage resulted in a lack of income for India of ₹1,010 crore in FY24. Income loss will improve as India has dedicated to make tariffs zero on limitless portions of silver from the UAE inside subsequent 8 years,” it added.

It mentioned this commerce is uncommon as a result of the UAE simply imports giant silver and gold bars, soften and convert these into silver grains and unwrought gold for exports. “A test with world refiners will present that worth addition in such course of is way lower than 1% versus 3% required beneath the FTA,” it mentioned.

On gold bars, the report mentioned India agreed to import 200 metric tonmes of gold yearly from the UAE with a 1% tariff concession and as a consequence of this gold imports rose 147.6% from $3 billion in FY23 to $7.6 billion in FY24, inflicting India to lose ₹635 crore in income in FY24.

Equally, India’s jewelry imports have elevated 187.6% from $1.1 billion in FY23 to $3.3 billion in FY24, whereas these imports from the UAE have elevated 290% from $347 million in FY23 to $1.35 billion within the final fiscal.